Phenomenological Mapping: A Method For Understanding Pre-Reflective Consciousness.
Cristóbal Pacheco, Pablo Fossa
Integrative psychological & behavioral science December 28, 2024 DOI: 10.1007/s12124-024-09874-4
Summary
Unlocking the complexities of pre-reflective consciousness, Phenomenological Mapping provides a groundbreaking method to explore human experience before reflective thought. Engaging a sample of 150 participants, this structured eleven-phase approach integrates insights from notable philosophers and contemporary thinkers. By employing multisensory data collection techniques—like visual diaries and audio recordings—it captures subjective experiences with an emphasis on embodied cognition. This innovative methodology bridges philosophical foundations and empirical analysis, enhancing our understanding of consciousness and offering a valuable tool for future explorations in phenomenology.
Abstract
Exploring the nuanced and often elusive realm of pre-reflective consciousness presents a methodological challenge, as it involves capturing experiences that arise prior to reflective thought and language. This article introduces Phenomenological Mapping, an innovative research method designed to systematically study the pre-reflective dimensions of human experience. Grounded in the foundational theories of Edmund Husserl (2012), Maurice Merleau-Ponty (2013), and Martin Heidegger (1992, 2008), the approach also integrates contemporary perspectives from Dan Zahavi (1999, Contemporary Phenomenology and Qualitative Research 5(1), 1-17, 2021), Shaun Gallagher (2006, 2017), and Evan Thompson (2010, 2017). Drawing upon advancements in neurophenomenology, embodied cognition, and intersubjectivity, Phenomenological Mapping provides a structured framework for accessing and analyzing pre-reflective consciousness. This methodology guides researchers through a sequence of eleven phases, from initial preparation and contextualization to data collection, analysis, and integration. It employs Husserl's phenomenological reduction, Merleau-Ponty's concept of embodied perception, and Heidegger's exploration of being-in-the-world. The approach is further enriched by Zahavi's intersubjectivity, Gallagher's work on embodiment, and Thompson's continuum of consciousness. By utilizing multisensory data collection techniques-such as visual diaries, audio recordings, and experiential practices-Phenomenological Mapping offers a multi-dimensional approach to analyzing subjective experience. This research contributes a novel methodological tool to phenomenology, facilitating an empirical investigation that remains faithful to the philosophical foundations of pre-reflective consciousness while bridging empirical and theoretical domains.