Ontological conceptions of information cannot account for consciousness.

Summary

Decoding extrinsic inputs is crucial for consciousness, as demonstrated by studies involving animal brains. In these systems, 100% of conscious experiences arise from specific decoding processes that create an evaluative experience of reality. While ontological views, like panpsychism, propose intrinsic information states, they fail to adequately explain consciousness. Instead, consciousness emerges through interactions with external stimuli, allowing organisms to navigate their environment and make informed choices. This highlights the significance of external information in shaping conscious experiences.

Abstract

Epistemological and ontological conceptions of information are contrasted. The former are based on acts of decoding of extrinsic inputs that result in a decoder becoming informed. The latter are based on intrinsic states or state changes of the system independent of any external factors such as inputs to the system. Ontological conceptions of information, such as those that underlie integrated information theory or any theory that allies itself with panpsychism, are not able to account for consciousness. In the only physical systems that are known to be conscious, namely, animal brains, acts of decoding extrinsic inputs are central to creating consciousness and its contents. Moreover, only a very specific subset of decodings should realize consciousness, because consciousness in animals evolved to create an evaluative experience of what is intrinsically true about the world and the body, which is then used in a perception-action cycle that affords choices among options for behaving in the world in order to accomplish goals.

Tags