Taking subjectivity seriously: towards a unification of phenomenology, psychiatry, and neuroscience.

Summary

Psychiatric diseases alter subjective experience, but neuroscience typically focuses on objective measures. Phenomenology, a philosophical tradition studying lived experience, can bridge this gap. Early phenomenologically-oriented psychiatrists made contributions, but this approach faded with operationalized diagnoses. Recently, it has re-emerged. The authors argue that phenomenological research can generate hypotheses about the neurobiological basis of mental illness, using mania and psychosis as examples. They propose integrating phenomenological investigations with modern neuroscience through a cross-species approach, emphasizing human subjects research to unify understanding of mental illness biology.

Study at a glance

Abstract

Nearly all psychiatric diseases involve alterations in subjective, lived experience. The scientific study of the biological basis of mental illness has generally focused on objective measures and observable behaviors, limiting the potential for our understanding of brain mechanisms of disease states and possible treatments. However, applying methods designed principally to interpret objective behavioral measures to the measurement and extrapolation of subjective states presents a number of challenges. In order to help bridge this gap, we draw on the tradition of phenomenology, a philosophical movement concerned with elucidating the structure of lived experience, which emerged in the early 20th century and influenced philosophy of mind, cognitive science, and psychiatry. A number of early phenomenologically-oriented psychiatrists made influential contributions to the field, but this approach retreated to the background as psychiatry moved towards more operationalized disease classifications. Recently, clinical-phenomenological research and viewpoints have re-emerged in the field. We argue that the potential for phenomenological research and methods to generate productive hypotheses about the neurobiological basis of psychiatric diseases has thus far been underappreciated. Using specific examples drawing on the subjective experience of mania and psychosis, we demonstrate that phenomenologically-oriented clinical studies can generate novel and fruitful propositions for neuroscientific investigation. Additionally, we outline a proposal for more rigorously integrating phenomenological investigations of subjective experience with the methods of modern neuroscience research, advocating a cross-species approach with a key role for human subjects research. Collaborative interaction between phenomenology, psychiatry, and neuroscience has the potential to move these fields towards a unified understanding of the biological basis of mental illness.