Self-Reported Efficacy of Treatments in Cluster Headache: a Systematic Review of Survey Studies

A systematic review of nine retrospective surveys involving 5,419 respondents found that oxygen and subcutaneous triptan injections were most often reported as effective abortive treatments for cluster headache, while psilocybin and lysergic acid diethylamide (LSD) were most commonly reported as effective prophylactic treatments. The reported efficacy of most substances was consistent across different surveys, and the order of efficacy generally agreed with clinical studies. The findings suggest that retrospective surveys can provide supporting information on treatment effects and generate hypotheses about novel therapies. The consistently reported efficacy of psilocybin and LSD in prophylactic treatment indicates a need for clinical studies.

Study at a glance

Abstract

Abstract Purpose of Review The use and efficacy of various substances in the treatment of CH have been studied in several retrospective surveys. The aim of the study is to systematically review published survey studies to evaluate the reported efficacies of both established and unconventional substances in abortive and prophylactic treatment of both episodic and chronic CH, specifically assessing the consistency of the results. Recent Findings No systematic review have been conducted of these studies previously. A systematic literature search with a set of search terms was conducted on PubMed. Retrospective surveys that quantified the self-reported efficacy of two or more CH treatments, published in English during 2000–2020, were included. Several key characteristics and results of the studies were extracted. A total of 994 articles were identified of which 9 were found to be eligible based on the selection criteria. In total, 5419 respondents were included. Oxygen and subcutaneous triptan injections were most reported as effective abortive treatments, while psilocybin and lysergic acid diethylamide were most commonly reported as effective prophylactic treatments. The reported efficacy of most substances was consistent across different studies, and there were marked differences in the reported efficacies of different substances. The reported order of efficacy is generally in agreement with clinical studies. The findings suggest that retrospective surveys can be used to obtain supporting information on the effects of various substances used in the treatment of CH and to form hypotheses about novel treatment methods. The consistently reported efficacy of psilocybin and LSD in prophylactic treatment indicates need for clinical studies.