Evidence of a hierarchical representation in bodily self-consciousness: the neural correlates of embodiment and presence in virtual worlds.

Bodily self-consciousness (BSC) comprises embodiment—the sense of owning a body—and presence—the sense of being at a location. Evidence suggests these rely on partly distinct neural networks, but how they interact remains unclear. A model is proposed in which presence depends on embodiment. In a virtual-reality experiment, correlated versus uncorrelated sensory feedback manipulated embodiment, and first- versus third-person perspective manipulated presence. Behavioral performance (reaction times and accuracy) improved with correlated feedback and first-person perspective. Functional MRI revealed frontoparietal areas supporting embodiment and temporoparietal areas supporting presence. Manipulations of embodiment produced larger effect sizes in presence-related areas than vice versa, and this pattern held for overlapping areas. The data indicate that presence-related brain areas may depend on activity in embodiment-related networks.

Study at a glance

Abstract

Bodily Self-Consciousness (BSC) is the perception of bodily awareness that arises from the integration of neuronal signals in multiple sensory modalities. BSC is composed of embodiment (the perception of owning a body) and presence (the perception of being at a location). Converging lines of evidence suggest embodiment and presence are supported by different neural networks. Several models have been proposed to describe how BSC manifests from these networks, but how these networks interact is not fully understood. We propose that the perception of presence is predicated upon the perception of embodiment. Specifically, even though neural networks for presence and embodiment partially overlap, there exists a subset of brain areas that mediate the flow of information from those supporting embodiment to those supporting presence. To test this model, sensory feedback was manipulated in a virtual environment to affect BSC, while measuring behavioral performance and physiological responses in relevant brain areas. Correlated versus uncorrelated feedback was used to manipulate perceptions of embodiment. First- versus third-person perspective was used to manipulate perceptions of presence. Mean reaction times and accuracy were better with correlated feedback and first-person perspective. Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) measurements of neuronal activity identified frontoparietal and temporoparietal brain areas that appear to support embodiment and presence, respectively. We compared the effect of embodiment manipulations on presence areas and vice versa. The effect sizes for manipulations of embodiment were greater than those for manipulations of presence. This trend was also observed for brain areas that appeared to encode both embodiment and presence. This data indicates that networks associated with embodiment and presence overlap, and brain areas that support presence may depend upon the activity of those that support embodiment.