Standards Without Labs: Drug Development in the Psychedelic Underground
Citizen Science Theory and Practice – January 01, 2022
Source: OpenAlex
Summary
An online network, Clusterbusters, developed a standardized protocol for using homegrown psilocybe mushrooms as a cluster headache treatment, challenging traditional medicine. Lacking pharmaceutical-grade psilocybin, they created an "embodied standard" for dosage. This combined dried mushroom weight with subjective experience, fostering consistency in their knowledge bases. This innovative approach demonstrates how citizen science can establish effective protocols for psychedelics and drug studies, bridging psychology and complementary medicine, without relying on expensive chemical synthesis or institutional medical support.
Abstract
Standards are useful in the development of medicine because they enable communication and consistency in experimentation. Standards, however, often require expensive tools like laboratories and clinical trials. How, then, might citizen scientists develop standards given the difficulty of obtaining these tools? This article provides one answer, by describing how Clusterbusters, a non-profit organization that represents an online network of people with cluster headache, developed a standardized protocol for using psychedelic mushrooms as a treatment for their disease without the assistance of laboratory equipment or institutional scientific support. In a multi-sited, digital ethnographic investigation of Clusterbusters, we find they used multiple strategies to standardize their experiments. Clusterbusters consumed their medicine in the form of homegrown psilocybe mushrooms because they lacked access to pharmaceutical-grade psilocybin. A dose of a mushroom cannot be standardized as easily as an isolated chemical, yet each individual experimenter needed to understand how much psychedelic they were about to consume. They solved their problem by developing an “embodied standard” for dosage that combined both the weight of the dried mushroom and the subjective experience the dosage produced. This hybrid measure enabled Clusterbusters to develop a collective phenomenological understanding of a standard dosage. Our discussion highlights how the pragmatic goals of knowledge production of citizen science differ from the institutionalized scientists’ need to legitimate their findings with academic journals, peers, and regulatory agencies. This insight may be useful not only for those who study citizen science, but also those who work with institutionalized protocols in other domains.