Respiratory depression in women receiving propofol/esketamine versus propofol/fentanyl for abortion surgery or curettage: a randomized clinical trial.
Annals of medicine – December 01, 2025
Source: PubMed
Summary
A groundbreaking clinical trial reveals a safer anesthetic option for women undergoing abortion surgery. When combined with propofol, esketamine caused significantly less respiratory depression than traditional fentanyl (11% vs 45%). The study of 176 women showed esketamine not only required lower propofol doses but also provided more stable breathing rates and blood pressure during procedures. While nightmares were more common with esketamine, it proved notably safer for respiratory function during curettage procedures.
Abstract
A combination of opioids with propofol is a popular approach to non-intubated general anaesthesia; however, this method usually results in higher incidence of respiratory depression. We compared the incidence of esketamine- and fentanyl-induced respiratory depression in women undergoing abortion surgery or curettage under propofol-based non-intubated general anaesthesia. This study included 176 women (aged 18-60 years) scheduled for abortion surgery or curettage. Patients were randomized into the fentanyl or esketamine groups. Patients in the fentanyl group received fentanyl (1 µg/kg) combined with propofol intravenously. Patients in the esketamine group received subanaesthetic doses of esketamine (0.15 mg/kg) combined with propofol intravenously. The primary outcome was the incidence of respiratory depression during anaesthesia. Secondary outcomes included respiratory rate, pulse oximetry, blood pressure, heart rate, propofol dose, duration of surgery, duration of anaesthesia, and adverse events. The incidence of respiratory depression in the esketamine group was significantly lower than that in the fentanyl group (11% vs. 45%; p < .0001). Propofol administration was lower with esketamine than fentanyl. Respiratory rate, SpO2 and blood pressure were more stable in the esketamine group than in the fentanyl group. The incidences of hypotension, propofol-induced injection pain and chin lifting in the esketamine group were lower than those in the fentanyl group. The incidence of nightmares was higher in the esketamine than in the fentanyl group. The incidence of respiratory depression was lower with subanaesthetic doses of esketamine than with fentanyl in women undergoing abortion surgery or curettage under propofol-based non-intubated general anaesthesia.KEY MESSAGESOpioids combined with propofol is a popular method for non-intubated general anaesthesia; however, this method usually results in higher incidence of respiratory depression.At subanaesthetic doses, esketamine provides an analgesic effect by antagonizing the N-methyl-d-aspartate receptor.In this trial, the incidence of respiratory depression was lower with subanaesthetic doses of esketamine than with fentanyl in women undergoing abortion surgery or curettage under propofol-based non-intubated general anaesthesia.