Plant Agency in the Guianas: Attraction, Assault, and Animacy
James Andrew Whitaker, Vikram Tamboli, Lewis Daly, Matthias Lewy
Journal of Ethnobiology September 22, 2024 Peer reviewed DOI: 10.1177/02780771241277618 via OpenAlex
Summary
Indigenous peoples in the Guianas, including the Makushi, Pemon, and Karinya, regard certain plants as animate, agentive beings. Based on ethnographic and ethnobotanical fieldwork in Guyana and Venezuela, this article examines how these plant persons act within contexts of subsistence, shamanism, assault sorcery, and romantic attraction. Today, these territories overlap with extractive frontiers such as gold mining and forestry, where plants also emerge as active agents. The article contrasts archival representations with contemporary accounts and explores how shamans, hunters, gardeners, and miners relate to these animate plants.
Study at a glance
| Design | qualitative study |
|---|---|
| Population | Makushi, Pemon, Karinya, and other Indigenous and mixed-Indigenous peoples in the Guianas |
| Key finding | Plants are regarded as animate, agentive beings that exert special botanical agencies in subsistence, shamanism, sorcery, and extractive contexts among Indigenous communities in the Guianas. |
Abstract
This article uses ethnographic and ethnobotanical methods to examine relationships between animate and agentive plants and human beings among the Makushi, Pemon, Karinya, and other Indigenous and mixed-Indigenous peoples in the Guianas. It considers representations of these plants and related ontologies in the archival record and contrasts these accounts with more recent ethnographic descriptions based on the authors’ fieldwork across Guyana and Venezuela. It thinks about these plants as agentive beings (with regard to animist ontologies and sometimes physical properties) within a variety of contexts. Today, the territories of these Indigenous peoples tessellate with extractive frontiers, which center around gold, diamond, and bauxite mining, as well as oil prospecting, forestry, and plantation agriculture. In this context, these plants emerge as active and animate agents. They also emerge as such agents in contexts of subsistence, shamanism, and assault sorcery, as well as sexual and romantic attraction, which can act with or without human impetus. The question arises as to the nature of the relationships between such plants and their users, for example, shamans ( piaimen ), assault sorcerers ( kanaima ), hunters, gardeners, and miners, within a variety of contexts. Based on the authors’ long-term fieldwork, the article examines animate plants and argues that they evince special botanical agencies among the Indigenous communities with whom the authors have worked in the Guianas. How are animate plants positioned within these practices and contexts? And how do they exert agency therein as plant persons?