Skip to content

Jacob S Aday

Department of Anesthesiology, University of Michigan Medical School, Ann Arbor, MI, United States.

10 papers in the library · 95 citations · publishing 2024-2026

Papers

Psychedelic-assisted psychotherapy: where is the psychotherapy research?

Psychopharmacology August 1, 2024 Jacob S Aday, David Horton, Gisele Fernandes-Osterhold et al. 39 citations

Psychedelic-assisted psychotherapy (PAP) shows promise for treating mental health conditions like substance use disorders and depression, yet the role of the psychotherapy component itself has received little empirical scrutiny. This review examines current debates over whether PAP involves full psychotherapy or merely psychological support, and summarizes existing clinical trial models and theoretical frameworks. It draws lessons from traditional psychotherapy research, advocating for standardized treatment manuals, clear provider eligibility criteria, measurement of established mechanisms of change, and optimized trial designs such as dismantling studies and comparative efficacy trials. The authors argue that PAP is a distinct, integrative, transdisciplinary intervention requiring further research into its psychotherapeutic components to inform best practices and federal guidelines.

Psychedelic Therapist Sexual Misconduct and Other Adverse Experiences Among a Sample of Naturalistic Psychedelic Users.

Psychedelic medicine (New Rochelle, N.Y.) March 1, 2025 Daniel J Kruger, Jacob S Aday, Christopher W Fields et al. 19 citations

In an anonymous online survey of 1,221 people who reported past psychedelic use, most described adverse experiences: 74.3% felt frightened, 58.6% sadness, 54.3% body shaking or trembling, and 51.6% loneliness. About half reported some other adverse experience, and one in ten had adverse physical reactions. One-third knew someone arrested for possession or use of psychedelics; 8% reported that they or someone they know was the victim of inappropriate sexual contact by a psychedelic sitter, guide, or practitioner; and one-quarter knew someone who experienced a severe adverse event other than inappropriate sexual contact or arrest. The findings indicate that despite beneficial effects, psychedelic experiences can be challenging, distressing, or harmful, highlighting the need to prevent, identify, manage, and treat adverse events.

Effects of Ayahuasca on Gratitude and Relationships with Nature: A Prospective, Naturalistic Study.

Journal of psychoactive drugs January 1, 2025 Jacob S Aday, Emily K Bloesch, Alan K Davis et al. 16 citations

People who attended an ayahuasca retreat reported lasting increases in gratitude, feeling connected to nature, and appreciating nature. Surveys of 54 participants taken one week before, one week after, and one month after the retreat showed significant improvements at both follow-ups compared to baseline. The intensity of mystical-type experiences and awe during ayahuasca sessions weakly to moderately correlated with these increases, while the number of ceremonies attended did not. Older participants reported less intense mystical and awe experiences. The findings suggest that the quality of psychedelic experiences, particularly mystical and awe states, may foster prosocial changes in gratitude and nature connection.

Psychedelic substitution: altered substance use patterns following psychedelic use in a global survey.

Frontiers in psychiatry January 1, 2024 Nicolas G Glynos, Jacob S Aday, Daniel Kruger et al. 15 citations

A large global survey of 5,268 adults who had used psychedelics found that nearly three-quarters (70.9%) reported ceasing or decreasing use of at least one non-psychedelic substance afterward. Among those who had previously used specific substances, 60.6% decreased alcohol use, 55.7% decreased antidepressant use, and 54.2% decreased cocaine or crack use. Over a quarter said the decrease lasted 26 weeks or longer. However, 19.8% reported increased or initiated use of other substances, most commonly illicit opioids (14.7%) and cannabis (13.3%). Factors linked to decreased use included motivation to reduce substance use or self-treat a medical condition; increased use was associated with higher income and residing in Canada or the US.

Racial Differences in Naturalistic Psychedelic Use - Motivations for Use, Communication with Health Care Providers, and Outcomes.

Journal of psychoactive drugs April 22, 2025 Nicolas G Glynos, Mallet R Reid, Jacob S Aday et al. 4 citations

People of Color have been underrepresented in psychedelic-assisted therapy (PAT) research, and some have suggested that systemic harms like the War on Drugs and discrimination in healthcare might reduce their willingness to participate. A large-scale survey of people using psychedelics in North America compared 3,547 White people, 448 People of Color, and 377 Multiracial people. A lower proportion of People of Color used psychedelics with a trained provider, but equal proportions had disclosed psychedelic use to primary care providers, were equally motivated to use psychedelics with a trained provider, used psychedelics for similar issues, and reported similar effectiveness. The findings suggest that lack of trust may not fully explain underrepresentation, and other barriers should be investigated.

Extended difficulties after psychedelic experiences: Prevalence and associations in a global, multilingual sample.

Research square April 8, 2026 Oliver C Robinson, David Luke, Jules Evans et al. 1 citation

In a large global online survey of 6,476 people who have used psychedelics, nearly half (48.3%) reported at least one difficulty lasting 24 hours or more, and 9.9% experienced difficulties for over a year. The most common difficulties were existential struggle (36.6%), depression (34%), and derealization (29.4%). Existential struggle was rated as the most severe difficulty but also the one most linked to healing. Clinically relevant disruptive difficulties lasting at least a month and disrupting daily life were reported by 8% of participants and were associated with younger age, lower income, lack of family support, lower emotional stability, higher pre-existing anxiety or depression, and using psychedelics to treat mental health conditions. The findings highlight the need for education on risks and benefits, safety guidelines, and support services.

Pictorial representation of illness and self measure (PRISM): A putative transdiagnostic tool for evaluating therapeutic effects of psychedelic treatments.

Journal of psychopharmacology (Oxford, England) May 1, 2025 Niloufar Pouyan, Jacob S Aday, Steven E Harte et al. 1 citation

People with treatment-resistant conditions often see their illness as part of their identity. The pictorial representation of illness and self measure (PRISM) gauges this self-condition enmeshment. In a survey of 297 individuals who used psychedelics therapeutically on their own, most reported symptom improvement: 95.4% with depression, 98.36% with posttraumatic stress disorder, and 94.87% with anxiety. PRISM scores dropped significantly after the most salient psychedelic experience, indicating reduced identification with the condition. The decrease in PRISM scores correlated with symptom improvement across all conditions. PRISM appears useful for tracking how psychedelics affect self-perception across diagnoses, though limitations include convenience sampling, potential positive bias, and retrospective reporting.

Classic Psychedelics for Chronic Pain: A Critical Review of the Literature and Practical Advice for Clinicians.

Drugs June 4, 2026 Kevin F Boehnke, Niloufar Pouyan, Jacob S Aday

Chronic pain is common, costly, and often poorly treated by existing therapies. Classic serotonergic psychedelics—psilocybin, LSD, ayahuasca, DMT, and mescaline—have re-emerged as potential tools for chronic pain, administered alone or within psychedelic-assisted therapy. This review examines mechanisms relevant to pain, including effects on neuroplasticity, inflammation, brain network dynamics, and psychological processes like pain acceptance and cognitive flexibility. Observational studies and early-phase clinical trials show preliminary signals of benefit for fibromyalgia, migraine, cluster headache, and other chronic pain syndromes. The field is limited by small sample sizes, functional unblinding, and a lack of large, well-controlled randomized trials. The authors outline methodological priorities and future research directions needed to rigorously evaluate these compounds for chronic pain.

Disengaged: A systematic review of community engagement in psychedelic-assisted therapy research.

Neuroscience and biobehavioral reviews February 1, 2026 Mallet R Reid, Jonathan Song, Kevin F Boehnke et al.

People of color have been significantly underincluded in psychedelic-assisted therapy (PAT) research, despite facing challenges commonly addressed in PAT and often more severe symptoms. A systematic review of the past 10 years of psilocybin, MDMA, and LSD clinical trials in the United States (N = 27) found that only 3 out of 27 studies (11.11%) incorporated community-engaged research (CEnR) practices. In the rare instances CEnR was integrated, researchers used community consultation, which involves relatively little engagement with community members. The authors recommend incorporating five CEnR principles to improve representation in PAT trials: mapping and engaging local stakeholders, leveraging existing university-hospital infrastructures, co-designing research and outreach initiatives, securing dedicated CEnR resources, and establishing mechanisms for ongoing evaluation.

Development of a mandarin version of the five dimensional altered states of consciousness (5D-ASC) rating scale.

Drug science, policy and law January 1, 2026 Jacob S Aday, Zoe Zong, Jonathan Song et al.

A Mandarin version of the Five Dimensional Altered States of Consciousness (5D-ASC) Rating Scale was developed to improve language accessibility for Mandarin-speaking individuals in psychedelic research. The translation followed the ISPOR Task Force guidelines, involving forward translation by two professionals, review by a native Mandarin speaker, back-translation, and comparison with the original. The scale includes 11 facets such as experience of unity, spiritual experience, and anxiety, and can also be analyzed using the original 5-factor structure. The full survey is provided in the appendix. Further research is needed to evaluate its reliability and validity in Mandarin-speaking populations.