Measuring and Understanding the Meaning of Exceptionalism to Bolster Ethics Oversight of Psychedelics Research
American Journal of Bioethics January 1, 2025 Naomi Scheinerman, Claire Erickson 1 citation
Exceptionalism in bioethics is the concept that certain medical developments or interventions deserve special ethical or legal treatment because of their distinctive characteristics. The work examines how this idea applies across various contexts, arguing that exceptionalism can both protect vulnerable populations and create unjustified distinctions that hinder equitable access or oversight. It explores the tension between recognizing genuine uniqueness in medical technologies or practices and the risk of overemphasizing differences at the expense of broader ethical principles. The authors suggest that careful analysis is needed to determine when exceptionalism is warranted and when it may lead to problematic inconsistencies in bioethical reasoning.