Equipoise and Personal Experience: Maintaining Objectivity in Psychedelic Research
American Journal of Bioethics January 1, 2025 Katrina Debonis, Walter Dunn, Thomas B. Strouse
The resurgence of psychedelic research raises ethical questions about whether facilitators should have personal psychedelic experience. Some argue that such experience is essential for effective and ethical facilitation, while others contend that it is unnecessary and may introduce bias. The authors examine these competing perspectives, weighing arguments about empathy, trust, and professional competence. They conclude that requiring personal experience could undermine scientific objectivity and equitable access to therapy, but also acknowledge that experiential knowledge may enhance therapeutic rapport. The paper calls for clearer ethical guidelines that balance these concerns without mandating personal use.