New England Journal of Medicine
May 24, 2023
A. Anand, S. Mathew, G. Sanacora et al.
263 citations
For treatment-resistant major depression without psychosis, intravenous ketamine is at least as effective as electroconvulsive therapy (ECT). In a randomized trial with 403 patients, 55.4% of those receiving ketamine and 41.2% of those receiving ECT showed a 50% or greater reduction in depression scores over three weeks. ECT was linked to a notable decline in memory recall after three weeks (average decrease of 9.7 points on a memory test vs. 0.9 points with ketamine), with gradual recovery during follow-up. Quality-of-life improvements were similar between groups. Ketamine caused dissociation, while ECT led to musculoskeletal side effects.
Contemporary Clinical Trials
February 1, 2019
S. Mathew, S. Wilkinson, Murat Altinay et al.
54 citations
Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) and ketamine show similar response rates for treatment-resistant depression, but a head-to-head comparison in a large, well-powered trial has been lacking. This protocol describes a non-inferiority trial randomizing 400 patients with treatment-resistant depression to receive either ECT thrice weekly or intravenous ketamine twice weekly for 3-5 weeks. The primary outcome is the proportion of responders based on a patient-reported depression scale. The study is designed to determine whether ketamine retains at least 90% of ECT's treatment effect. Results will inform patient choice, clinical practice, and insurance policies.
JAMA network open
June 3, 2024
Manish Kumar Jha, Samuel T Wilkinson, Kamini Krishnan et al.
29 citations
In people with treatment-resistant depression who do not have psychosis, intravenous ketamine works as well as electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) overall. Among outpatients with moderately severe or severe depression, ketamine produced greater improvement in depressive symptoms than ECT. In contrast, inpatients with very severe depression improved more with ECT early in treatment, though by the end of the three-week course both treatments were similarly effective. Higher premorbid intelligence and a diagnosis of posttraumatic stress disorder were linked to greater improvement with ECT, but not with ketamine. These findings may help patients and clinicians decide between the two treatments.
Psychiatry research
May 1, 2025
Gerard Sanacora, Brian S Barnett, Bo Hu et al.
2 citations
Patients with treatment-resistant depression who preferred ketamine over electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) were more likely to respond to treatment, regardless of which treatment they actually received. Matching patients to their preferred treatment improved response rates for ketamine but not for ECT, and reduced adverse events for ECT-treated patients. Ketamine was the more popular choice overall. The findings suggest that aligning treatment with patient preference can influence effectiveness, safety, and possibly adherence, but these effects vary by treatment modality and context.
Contemporary clinical trials
February 1, 2025
Noreen A Reilly-Harrington, Tatiana Falcone, David A Jobes et al.
A randomized controlled trial is testing whether ketamine infusions, compared to placebo, rapidly reduce severe suicidality in youth and young adults (ages 14-30) hospitalized with suicidal ideation or after a suicide attempt. Participants receive up to six treatments of ketamine or placebo while also engaging in Collaborative Assessment and Management of Suicidality (CAMS) sessions, a suicide-focused therapy, starting in the hospital and continuing after discharge. The study enrolls 140 participants and follows them for three months. The hypothesis is that ketamine will produce faster improvement in suicidality, enhance engagement in CAMS, and reduce suicide attempts, emergency visits, and readmissions compared to placebo.