Skip to content

Oxford Scholarship Online

15 papers in the library · 27 citations · publishing 2017-2018

Papers

Making Enactivism Even More Embodied

Oxford Scholarship Online August 24, 2017 Shaun Gallagher 12 citations

An enactivist approach to the mind goes beyond action and sensory-motor processes, incorporating affectivity and intersubjectivity. Affectivity in a broad sense—including hunger, fatigue, pain, respiration, and emotion—influences perception, attention, and judgment, as shown by empirical studies. Intersubjective factors such as bodily postures, movements, gestures, gaze, facial expressions, and dynamic interactions similarly affect cognition. This richer embodied view also has implications for understanding brain function.

Experience, Dreaming, and the Phenomenology of Wakeful Consciousness

Oxford Scholarship Online June 21, 2018 Thomas Crowther 10 citations

Wakeful consciousness contributes something distinctive to the stream of consciousness that is absent during non-wakeful states like dreaming. Assuming dreaming is a form of perceptual imagination, the chapter contrasts perceptual imagination when awake with that during dreaming sleep. Drawing on Brian O'Shaughnessy's ideas, it suggests that what is missing in dreaming is intentional mental action accompanied by non-inferential self-awareness. After critiquing O'Shaughnessy, the chapter proposes a 'Capacitation Thesis': wakefulness is a state of being capacitated with respect to relevant capacities. Dream imagination is then examined in light of this thesis.

Pushing Near-Death Experiences (I)

Oxford Scholarship Online September 20, 2018 Jens Schlieter 1 citation

A long-term shift in Western societies toward 'privatized death'—dying in hospitals and institutions—served as a 'push factor' for the articulation of near-death experiences. The chapter argues that near-death experiences can be partly read as a 'spiritual protest' against alienated, anonymous dying in institutions and the materialist approach of modern biomedicine that merely prolongs life. This protest is also present in criticisms of the 'denial of death.'

Pushing Near-Death Experiences (II)

Oxford Scholarship Online September 20, 2018 Jens Schlieter 1 citation

A second factor driving the rise in near-death experiences and their reporting during the 1960s and 1970s was the development of new reanimation techniques, which increased the number of people surviving critical events like heart attacks. The chapter also examines how the widely accepted redefinition of death as irreversible coma influenced near-death experiences and the surrounding discourse. This impact is evident in the work of Raymond Moody, who remained skeptical of the brain-death definition.

A Cross-Cultural Defense of the Epistemic Value of Mystical Experience

Oxford Scholarship Online November 22, 2018 Ayon Maharaj

Sri Ramakrishna's mystical testimony strengthens the case for taking mystical experiences as veridical. The chapter argues that his views support Robert Oakes's position that self-authenticating experiences of God are possible. It also uses Sri Ramakrishna's teachings to defend the argument from experience—the claim that God's existence can reasonably be inferred from the testimony of those who report experiencing Him. The author contends that this approach addresses two major objections to that argument: the lack of adequate cross-checkability and the problem of conflicting claims among different religious traditions.

Gender in Sámi Shamanism

Oxford Scholarship Online March 22, 2018 Trude Fonneland

Shamans in Norway draw on historical narratives to shape contemporary understandings of gender, revealing how religion and culture are embedded in social and gendered realities. The chapter argues that religion serves as a key mechanism for producing and enacting gender stereotypes, and by examining these practices, it localizes abstract religious concepts within concrete social contexts.

Psychedelic Last Rites

Oxford Scholarship Online March 22, 2018 Wayne Glausser

This chapter compares the Catholic sacrament of extreme unction with modern psychedelic therapy for the dying. Extreme unction, a final ritual fortifying the soul for heaven, is embraced by Catholics but viewed by Protestants as fraudulent. Since the 1960s and recently, psychiatrists have used LSD and psilocybin to help terminal cancer patients with anxiety and depression. The chapter explores how this psychedelic therapy shares the high purposes of extreme unction and some of its surrounding problems.

The Development of Sámi Shamanism

Oxford Scholarship Online March 22, 2018 Trude Fonneland

The chapter examines how shamanism in Norway evolves through the interaction of global spiritual currents with local culture. It focuses on the creative processes that occur when practitioners blend American Indian symbolism with perceived local traditions, sparking spiritual seekers to develop new religious movements. The analysis highlights how global shamanic culture influences and is adapted within Norwegian society, leading to innovative spiritual expressions that bridge the local and the global.

Ecstasy-Belonging in Madagascar and Brazil

Oxford Scholarship Online December 21, 2017 Kélina Gotman

Anti-colonial uprisings in Madagascar and Brazil were diagnosed as choreomania by missionary physicians and neuroscientists, who framed trance-like demonstrations—involving shaking, frothing, falling, and visions—as pathological movement disorders. Unlike earlier cases, these large-scale protests entered government administration, with physicians arguing that choreomania spread by pathological sympathy. In Madagascar, demonstrators angered at missionaries' black hats gathered at sacred sites, convulsing, and unseated a pro-European king, representing a form of ecstasy-belonging and a choreopolitics of revolt. In Brazil, revolutionary underclasses were dismissed as suffering a choreomaniacal epidemic of religious psychosis.

American Civil Mysticism

Oxford Scholarship Online November 23, 2017 Michelle Sizemore

A largely overlooked tradition of mysticism in post-revolutionary U.S. society, termed civil mysticism, involves nonsectarian practices of transcendence that engender the people through political and social rituals like maypole ceremonies, presidential inaugurations, and literary pilgrimages. The chapter elaborates on civil mysticism's conditions and techniques, emphasizing the sacred interval of ritual with its embodied practices, sensuous objects, and cognitive states. Drawing on Nathaniel Hawthorne's "The Maypole of Merry Mount" and other nineteenth-century depictions, it argues that civil mysticism managed the democratic representational conundrum of being plural at the same time as being one.

How Meditation Works

Oxford Scholarship Online October 19, 2017 David L. Mcmahan

Meditation is often described as producing internal states that arise from diligent practice, but these practices only function within specific social and cultural contexts, and their effects vary across different settings. McMahan theorizes meditation as cultivating ways of being within particular social imaginaries, which are shaped by cultural repertoires of concepts, attitudes, social practices, ethical dispositions, institutions, power relations, identities, authority structures, and cosmic conceptions. This theory draws on studies of historical psychosomatic illnesses, which show that eras generate specific symptom pools. Recontextualizing meditation as a cultural practice highlights the need for humanistic study and shows that a totalizing neurophysiological explanation of meditation is impossible.

Variations on Embodied Cognition

Oxford Scholarship Online August 24, 2017 Shaun Gallagher

A range of embodied cognition (EC) theories are mapped, from 'weak EC'—which retains traditional cognitivist ideas by focusing on body-formatted representations and neural reuse—to functionalist extended-mind proposals, a biological model, and enactivist views. Each approach is examined alongside supporting empirical evidence. The chapter argues that weak EC's representationalist view of brain function is incompatible with more radical EC theories, which reconceive the brain as part of a dynamic brain–body–environment system.

A Space with No Place (Straus and Ecstasy)

Oxford Scholarship Online June 22, 2017 Frédéric Pouillaude

Erwin Straus argues that dance belongs to smooth, acoustic space, which contrasts with the optical space of directed, purposeful movement. Music enables dance by creating a homogeneous, nebulous acoustic space where the directionality of praxis is obliterated. Optical space is described as historical, while acoustic space is presentic. Dance, as an extension of music, allows a presentic relation to space called ecstasy or becoming one, which is most apparent in dances that are not yet dances, such as children's dances, social dances, or primitive dances.